Jeremiah Service House is an Italianate house in New Carlisle, Indiana, and a filming location for Prancer (1989). Built in 1860, and is listed on the U.S. National Register of Historic Places.
Location: New Carlisle, Indiana, United States
Verified facts
- Located in New Carlisle
confidence 80/100 · 4 independent sources · SRC-2551, SRC-2552, SRC-7831, SRC-7832 - Appeared in Prancer (movie, 1989)
confidence 80/100 · 6 independent sources · SRC-2553, SRC-2552, SRC-2554, SRC-7833, SRC-7834, SRC-9287 - Built in 1860
confidence 75/100 · 4 independent sources · SRC-2555, SRC-2552, SRC-7835, SRC-9288 - Architectural style: Italianate
confidence 90/100 · 4 independent sources · SRC-2555, SRC-2552, SRC-7832, SRC-7835 - Historic designation: National Register of Historic Places
confidence 90/100 · 4 independent sources · SRC-2553, SRC-2555, SRC-7832, SRC-7831
Evidence & sources
- SRC-2551 — Wikipedia — National Register of Historic Places listings in St. Joseph County, Indiana (Tier 3, encyclopedia; retrieved June 2026)
- SRC-2552 — Masco Salvage — The Renovation of Indiana's Old Republic Service Home (Tier 3, established_blog; retrieved June 2026)
- SRC-2553 — Wikipedia — New Carlisle, Indiana (Tier 3, encyclopedia; retrieved June 2026)
- SRC-2554 — Odd Things I've Seen — Sam Elliott vs. a Reindeer: Prancer Filming Sites (Tier 3, established_blog; retrieved June 2026)
- SRC-2555 — Historic New Carlisle, Inc. — The Old Republic (Tier 2, institutional; retrieved June 2026)
- SRC-7831 — National Register of Historic Places — Notification of Pending Nominations (65 FR 9295) — Federal Register (Tier 1, government; retrieved June 2026)
- SRC-7832 — Service, Jeremiah H., House — National Register of Historic Places, NPGallery (National Park Service) (Tier 1, government; retrieved June 2026)
- SRC-7833 — Christmas Movie Locations That Exist in Real Life — Reader's Digest (Tier 2, web; retrieved June 2026)
- SRC-7834 — Filming Locations of Chicago and Los Angeles: Prancer — itsfilmedthere.com (Tier 3, web; retrieved June 2026)
- SRC-7835 — 10 Most Endangered Success Stories — Indiana Landmarks (Tier 2, web; retrieved June 2026)
- SRC-9287 — Prancer (1989) — AFI Catalog of Feature Films, American Film Institute (Tier 1, official_archive; retrieved June 2026)
- SRC-9288 — Jeremiah Service House — Wikipedia (Tier 2, encyclopedia; retrieved June 2026)
How we verify
Every fact above is independently corroborated by at least two reputable sources and
confidence-scored before publication. Claims that cannot clear that bar are withheld. We show the
street address only for non-residential public landmarks (museums, commercial and civic buildings,
publicly documented filming-location sites); the exact addresses of private residences and any
personal information are structurally barred from publication. Last reviewed June 2026.
Frequently asked questions
Where was Prancer filmed?
Jeremiah Service House, in New Carlisle, Indiana, is a real-world filming location used for Prancer.
Where is Jeremiah Service House located?
Jeremiah Service House is located in New Carlisle, Indiana.